I agree that they shouldn't be accepted as their own submissions but I do think having them isn't a bad thing. I like the idea of having them all on one sheet but that sheet would need to be updated constantly so it's not exactly a practical solution. Including them in a miscellaneous images sheet for a game is likely the easiest way but obviously not always applicable. Regardless of the final solution, I don't think any more of these should be accepted that the ones we already have should be removed (not necessarily immediately - we should find a suitable solution first).
I get what you're saying but I feel like that sheet would require updates far less frequently than a master game icons sheet. Still, it's a usable solution as long as it's updated occasionally. And with that sheet maker application, someone can just keep a folder of all of them and have it re-make the sheet automatically as necessary so it probably wouldn't be terribly difficult to maintain.
(09-19-2015, 10:19 PM)redblueyellow Wrote: That was the only thing that I was worried about. But in that case I would lump them into the same category as the downloadable content sheet from Pokemon Black/White.
http://www.spriters-resource.com/ds/poke...eet/34518/
Compared to the complete list of downloadable content, it is incomplete. http://www.serebii.net/blackwhite/global...oads.shtml
However, despite it being incomplete it should still be on the site. In the case of the game icon sheet, it could be updated whenever felt necessary and wouldn't have to be right after every new game comes out.
I get what you're saying but I feel like that sheet would require updates far less frequently than a master game icons sheet. Still, it's a usable solution as long as it's updated occasionally. And with that sheet maker application, someone can just keep a folder of all of them and have it re-make the sheet automatically as necessary so it probably wouldn't be terribly difficult to maintain.