11-24-2016, 12:09 AM
(11-23-2016, 01:37 PM)ShyGirl Wrote: How's this look? I know it's a little small, but I think it's not bad.
Well, the sprites are definitely too small.
Not to mention that the arms are just lines/curved lines with a border. The arms should definitely be thicker, and give it a thumb. See for reference: SMAS SMB2 Peach and Toad sprites (though their designs have changed since then, so be careful).
Size comparison would be a little bit bigger than SMAS SMB2 sprites of Peach and Toad. As in, if you wanted to do it to scale. Peach should probably be as tall as Yoshi in YI style, if you need a height reference.
Several details are also omitted, which can be fixed by making the sprites larger. Might I suggest looking at official character artwork of Peach and Toad for reference? For games to get a reference from in terms of official art, I recommend Super Mario 3D World (for Peach), and Mario Party 8 (for Toad).
There's also a ton of banding in the shading, which doesn't really make it look all that good.
I also recommend having your images hosted on a website like Imgur: http://imgur.com/ and linking them here inside [img][/img]tags instead of directly attaching them to your posts. Like this: [img]direct link to pic here[/img]