C+C And Style Discussion (Split from Nayr's Thread)

[Vipershark]

My issue here is that what Nayr is doing is literally edits and maybe some custom parts but overall edits.

This is NO different from someone doing sonic or megaman or mario edits which are obviously frowned upon here. The only difference is that this is bigger and looks a bit nicer due to the style.

So why is this considered acceptable while all the hundreds of other edits aren't?
What makes this okay?

Remember when all Iceman ever did was Mario and everyone jumped on him about it?
What's the difference? What makes Mario not okay but this okay? Where is the boundary drawn?