Nah I'm just trying to find a logical reason for these design choices. I mean why do you think he stuck with the Twilight Princess designs? It doesn't make sense.

Maybe he has a preference? It could be as simple as that

I assume partially because the look of the oot/tp designs are the ones that have been associated with SSB thus far. So basically, for consistency's sake, and to avoid betraying the expectations of people who have played with the oot/tp Zelda up until now. SS Zelda is a fairly big deviation, after all. Plus, she doesn't look like much of a fighter.

The Zelda in this SSB is probably closer to what most players associate with in their heads as "Zelda" in general. That gives it an "all-star" advantage, rather than being some one-off thing. The adjustments to Samus aren't big enough for that to really come into play with her decisions, I think.

I assume -mostly- that it has a lot to do with Ganondorf and Zelda. SS Zelda would make it difficult to incorporate Sheik, and I don't think they'd be comfortable with getting rid of Sheik at this point. You don't want to upset the people who main her(?)!

You could try to make some argument for Impa, but I'm pretty sure they'd see that as deviating too far from the character. I don't think Impa's even a big enough character to deserve to be included anyway. It comes across as a sort of lame fanfiction workaround. To my knowledge, Ganondorf is not even in SS, and thus has no SS design to incorporate. Link obviously has to fit in with his crew, so he can't exactly match his SS design either.

The compromises set in place make plenty of sense. I think it's a bit silly to treat their creative decisions as arbitrary. Sakurai's mentioned how seriously he takes them.

Yeah I'd assume Sheik or Ganondorf has something to do with it.

So uh

pretty much every time Koopaul posts is like this:

http://splicd.com/47aYnGZKpNw/97/128

Koopaul is Raven

(03-28-2014, 08:06 AM)Omega Wrote: I'm starting to get flashbacks to the old TSR Smash bros. Brawl thread, coulda sworn you made these same similar complaints then too Koopaul.

wasn't that back at pixeltendo

i remember i pissed some guy off back then because i kept insisting kracko and the spooky speedster would be playable and me and frario drew fan art of it

speaking about old pixeltendo/TSR back when Brawl speculation was a thing, anyone remember Slim Blue Wario?

I remember when some weirdos wanted Geno of all things then, and people were trying to figure out foreshadowing in clouds, and then there was the you must recover update.

Surprisingly, Geno was an excessively popular choice for Brawl because he was the most popular original character in Super Mario RPG. Sure, while Geno is a powerful character, I would rather have Mallow because he is more relatable and had better character development.

Yup. I still talk to Matt (Toadkarter) and Ricky (Metaknuckles) regularly at their YouTube channel and this gag gets brought up all the time.

Toadkarter, huh? I haven't heard about that guy in a long time! How is he doing these days?

(03-30-2014, 01:05 PM)Ton Wrote: Yup. I still talk to Matt (Toadkarter) and Ricky (Metaknuckles) regularly at their YouTube channel and this gag gets brought up all the time.

does Metaknuckles still do tribute comics with a guy named Jiggy?

(03-30-2014, 01:05 PM)Ton Wrote: Yup. I still talk to Matt (Toadkarter) and Ricky (Metaknuckles) regularly at their YouTube channel and this gag gets brought up all the time.

isn't this like toadkarter's shit? i thought someone posted this a while ago. i enjoyed that video
also is that josh guy that also contributes the joshi blue dressed afro guy who made a fuck ton of custom pokémon sheets for tsr?

also the only people i'm still in contact with are dazz, osm, starpower, shawn and occasionally frario and omgfossil
edit; and you guys who still remember me kiss kiss

Yep, that's them. I'm also in that video.

I sometimes try to talk to Starpower, I never really know how to get a hold of some of these guys.