10-08-2020, 04:03 PM
Sorry for the late reply for the first and second sprites.
First (recolors): Well, some of them look good, but some of them look weird. Like Luigi having green hair, Waluigi having a bright red nose, and Wario having yellow hair. But, I do understand why they look that way. I believe it's because of palette limitations, am I correct?
Second (Mario with captain hat): In my opinion, I think the one beside the last looks the best.
Third (enemies): The differences I can see are that Goomba's feet in the newer one looks better than the old one. Koopa Troopa's shoes look better in the new one and I like the shell on the new one. It has more animation to it, and it kind of looks like the SMW Koopa shell sprites. Piranha Plant plant looks better in the new one too, it makes him looks a lot like the one from SMAS SMB3, the old one looks more like the one from SMM SMB3.
One thing I would want to point out for Bob Omb is that the wind-up key looks like it's overlapping his body, but I think the explosion looks fine though.
For Monty Mole, they're not bad, but they're not the best though. Maybe you can use the Monty Mole from this sheet as a reference. It's not a bad attempt though.
For Bowser, I'd suggest making sprites for when he opens his mouth when he breathes fire, or try making some jump sprites. They're not bad either. I can see a lot of improvements for the enemies.
Fourth (Link): Not much to say about it, but it's looking good so far.
First (recolors): Well, some of them look good, but some of them look weird. Like Luigi having green hair, Waluigi having a bright red nose, and Wario having yellow hair. But, I do understand why they look that way. I believe it's because of palette limitations, am I correct?
Second (Mario with captain hat): In my opinion, I think the one beside the last looks the best.
Third (enemies): The differences I can see are that Goomba's feet in the newer one looks better than the old one. Koopa Troopa's shoes look better in the new one and I like the shell on the new one. It has more animation to it, and it kind of looks like the SMW Koopa shell sprites. Piranha Plant plant looks better in the new one too, it makes him looks a lot like the one from SMAS SMB3, the old one looks more like the one from SMM SMB3.
One thing I would want to point out for Bob Omb is that the wind-up key looks like it's overlapping his body, but I think the explosion looks fine though.
For Monty Mole, they're not bad, but they're not the best though. Maybe you can use the Monty Mole from this sheet as a reference. It's not a bad attempt though.
For Bowser, I'd suggest making sprites for when he opens his mouth when he breathes fire, or try making some jump sprites. They're not bad either. I can see a lot of improvements for the enemies.
Fourth (Link): Not much to say about it, but it's looking good so far.