games you dislike that everyone likes and vice versa

[Vipershark]

Oh by the way, I don't like Yoshi's Island.

I don't really like Yoshi as a character regardless (should have stayed as a rideable item) but outside of its graphics I think Yoshi's Island is a pretty overrated game.
The GBA version is slightly better than the SNES original, though.
YIDS is also bad but it's just a bad game regardless.

Haven't played Yoshi's Story yet so no comment on that one.