General Sonic is Terrible Thread

[Dolphman]

It's going to be live action, with the characters being made in CGI by Marza Animation Planet. Yeah, it does sound like a bad idea.
Firstly, most live action adaptations criminally focus more on the humans rather than the characters we came to see (IE, Transformers)
Second, how the hell are they going to make it work? Even with Sega supervising it, I just can't see him being made realistic.
The fan-film had the same problems mentioned above, and looked like a SyFy Mockbuster due to how low-budget it was.
But it HAS to be Roger Craig Smith doing the voice. Replacing him with a celebrity would indeed receive backlash.

This is why the Garfield movie didn't work: only he was CGI with a face that resembled a plush toy, Everyone else were normal animals.
And the plot was pretty much recycled from the TV special Here Comes Garfield. At least he had more screentime than Jon.
In my opinion, the writing would've been better if they hired Mark Evanier due to his work on Garfield & Friends.