General Sonic is Terrible Thread

[Iceman404]

Ugh do you really have to be that guy, in 2015? Really? Well here I go anyways.

Super Mario Sunshine (a bad experiment that fans want a sequel to)

Paper Mario Sticker Star (a game universally hated but everyone still has to have five things nice to say about it)

Spoiler

Advertisements for real cars in Mario Kart (something that SEGA was yelled at for doing)

Is this even a big deal or relevant?

Giveing us too many charicters to care about (Sonic and his friends are better)

Since when has Mario had too many characters aside from the silly clones with no series seen exclusively in only the recent spinoffs?

Not useing said charicters (look at Mario Party and Kart and tell me how many characters are filler. Baby, Cat, and Gold versions and mooks included)

They actually get a lot of shit for this

Say what you want about SEGA, they at lest try to lesten to thier fans.

They listen, they listen as well as a half-deaf man.

When Fans said they wanted less friends, we got Sonic 4.

That was a great game

When the fans said we want Tails back, we got Tails back.

Hoorah, we're getting content back that we had 20 years ago!

When the fans hated 06, the warehog, and about 20 other things, we did not see them agien (aside from 06 in Generations).

Well when their entire company is at stake for their own silly design shenanigans then of course they'll listen to their most vocal audience, sales!

The only thing that I can think of that Nintendo gave us was the original flying power-up, Yoshi, and more Fan service, Two of the three I could care less, and the third I'm starting to go the other way with.

The subjective

Sonic has had his bad games like Boom and 06, but Sonic Adventure is better made then Mario 64 and Sonic Heroes is a better game then Sunshine.

Any response to this sentence would get me an infraction for blatant trolling on my part.

There are more bad Mario games then Nintendo Fan boys want to admit, or do I have to bring up Sticker Star, New Super Mario Bros 2, The Lost Levels, Mario Party 1/9/10

1.) One mediocre game out of a thousand, 2.) not actually bad just unoriginal in changes, 3.) what, 4.) Again, rethink your definition of "bad". A lot of these just aren't great, a series is bound to get stale when it hits 10 but from a face-value view they're fine.

and (if we are going to count non-nintendo games)

So, even if I didn't argue the validity of the ridiculous stuff said here, what you're saying is that: 5% of Mario games are bad compared to Sonic's insane 60% or so. You really had to dig deep in there man.



SEGA is just a horrible company in general; for occasional flukes like the Virtual Boy that were only rough waters for a while, SEGA makes decisions like the Saturn that doom their entire company. Honestly, selling Sonic to Nintendo would be the safest bet at having quality games on a regular basis because they actually have the budget and care to put polish and good design into their titles. I actually don't feel like anything you said was really relevant to this point at all. For all your small nitpicks at Nintendo they usually do things better ten-fold, as much as you'd like to not believe it.

Sonic is in safer hands with them.