02-15-2012, 05:49 PM
All right, I finally got a chance to look at these.
The models themselves are pretty good. And technically, these could be accepted as they are now. However, I feel you can do more and make them even better submissions.
First off, having the PSKs is good, but having DAEs would be even better. Mighty Jetters wrote a nice guide on how to do this. It's easy to do, and definitely worth the effort.
Secondly, OBJ model files are (supposed to be) paired with MTL files, which define the textures on the model. With models like these, which only have one or two textures, it's not too much of a problem, but it does mean extra work for everyone who wants to use it. I recommend going back and adding them in.
I look forward to seeing your revised submissions.
The models themselves are pretty good. And technically, these could be accepted as they are now. However, I feel you can do more and make them even better submissions.
First off, having the PSKs is good, but having DAEs would be even better. Mighty Jetters wrote a nice guide on how to do this. It's easy to do, and definitely worth the effort.
Secondly, OBJ model files are (supposed to be) paired with MTL files, which define the textures on the model. With models like these, which only have one or two textures, it's not too much of a problem, but it does mean extra work for everyone who wants to use it. I recommend going back and adding them in.
I look forward to seeing your revised submissions.