Super Smash Bros. Melee rips

[Garamonde]

Or you can just, use the Icon Maker that's supposed to be used for making icons >.>

Or you don't have to... as long as he pastes the model render over the background then the border on top then they're fine (you can however save the blank icon with the text inputted from IM, then load it into your image program to place the image I guess).
No one wants to save each of those character renders individually just to load into Icon Maker. It's easier with Photoshop anyway because they require re-sizing.
For anyone who has Photoshop though I have a model icon template that easens the process a lot.