Sonic's 18th Birthday ^_^

[Rökkan]

ok so now we got some things that can make a perfect sonic game

I have some thoughts, too
-Maybe another 2.5D like in the sonic rival series, but it shouldn't be exclusive to the PSP imo
-fuck the voice acting altogether, it wasn't needed to begin with especially with shitty vioce overs in english
-Implement the 3D elements into 2D, this was accomplished in rom hacks of older games (cough cough Sonic MegaMix) so don't be telling me it can't work
lastly-No More New Characters there is already enough as is

what a terrible idea @ bold part
plus Sonic Rush already pretty much did it
there's no use for homming attack and a fuckzillion dashpads in a 2D game because Sonic has enough acceleration and top-speed to go through loopings and shit like that without needing to have the aid of dashpads, which it's pretty much why they were introduced.
Homming attack was introduced because it's hard to stomp over an enemy in a 3D environment, Super Mario 64 proved it. And in a gameplay that is supposed to be fast, this'd be complicated.

what Sonic games need to do is to introduce 2D elements into the 3D games, that is an stable engine that is very accurate to IRL physics, Sonic having the same acceleration and top-speed from the classics, Sonic builds up speed through momentum (like going through loopings and ladders) instead of dashpads, smart level design with tons of level-gimmicks that makes use of Sonic's speed and/or jumping abilities to get through, different Eggman robots with all sorts of attack patterns and design thematic that vary within the level, and of course, monitor/capsule items, that are pretty much being forgotten in the new games.
All of those things and maybe even more, then you'll get a good Sonic 3D game.